About the Elder Wand...

You remember when Deathly Hallows Part 2 came out and everyone made a fuss- and still do- about Harry snapping the Elder Wand in half and just throwing it away instead of putting it back in Dumbledore's tomb?

Here's my opinion- although I think the potential HBO TV adaptation should stick to the way the book played out, movie Harry didn't do anything wrong- here's why:

The Elder Wand can only be won by besting the previous owner.
This means that even if someone repaired the wand, they wouldn't be able to use it effectively because they didn't take it from Harry by force, like disarming him or something. So they've repaired it but they're using a wand that properly responds to someone else.  

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Potential Biographies/Autobiographies

This could be used to fill in missing information or plot holes or just as additional material for an already successful film/television franchise Riley Andersen ( Inside Out ) Troy Bolton ( High School Musical series) Jackie Burkhardt (That 70s Show) Martha Cox ( High School Musical series and High School Musical: the Musical: The Series ) Chad Danforth ( High School Musical series) James Edwards/Agent J ( Men in Black series) Eric Forman ( That 70s Show ) Laurie Forman ( That 70s Show ) Julie Gaffney ( Mighty Ducks franchise) Regina George ( Mean Girls ) Ste Hay ( Hollyoaks ) Cady Heron ( Mean Girls ) Steven Hyde ( That 70s Show ) Beth Johannsen ( The Martian ) Michael Kelso ( That 70s Show ) Kendra Mason from Degrassi - This would answer a long-standing question: why was she only at Degrassi Community School for one season? Spinner Mason ( Degrassi ) Taylor McKessie ( High School Musical  series) Lightning McQueen ( Cars series)  Gabriella Montez ( High School Musical ...
Read more

Thoughts on the Mysterious Benedict Society- Episodes 1 and 2

Phil Hay and Matt Manfredi deserve a ton of credit for writing Sticky's first scene in the pilot episode. In this brief clip, he gets a prize-money check but his parents take it away immediately. This, of course, is a reference to his backstory from the first book where his parents- after his increasing quiz show success- become more focused on the prizes he brings home than on his well-being. Episode 2 features a brief but very well-written moment courtesy of the same duo that beautifully captures Martina Crowe's personality, where she glares around the classroom and causes her fellow students to lower their raised hands. This is very much in keeping with Martina's "don't cross me" book personality. 
Read more

Why the MCU shouldn't recast T'Challa

T'Challa should remain Chadwick Boseman's role, and- at least in my opinion- casting another actor sort of dampens his legacy in that regard. I don't want this to be the same thing as Bruce Banner (remember Edward Norton in Incredible Hulk ?) or James Rhodes (remember Terrence Howard in Iron Man ?). One, and only one, person should portray T'Challa- the late Chadwick Boseman. Not having a T'Challa in the Black Panther sequel will allow the cast to grieve and mourn and honor- whichever they feel is appropriate- the life and legacy of both T'Challa (when cameras are rolling) and Chadwick (when cameras aren't rolling). Adding another actor as T'Challa- I think- would provide a "back to business as usual" vibe whereas keeping T'Challa's spot in Wakanda empty would allow the grieving process to continue on the actors' terms before, during and after filming, which in this regard I think is important. 
Read more